True Confessions

I'm a woman in a man's body

Woman's Day reader
Sunday, December 11, 2011
Happy couple
"I always knew I was female in a male body, long before I was even old enough to articulate that. I'm tall, slim and blonde and ever since I was very young I could easily pass for female, moreover I feel so much more comfortable as a female – it’s natural for me."
Woman's Day reader
My boyfriend Drew comes from a very close family and I'm pretty sure no woman would ever have been quite good enough for him in their eyes. If they were to ever find out the truth about me I hate to think what would happen.

So I had mixed feelings when I heard his mother discussing me at a family party "Ali's very pretty and has lovely manners, " she said approvingly and I smiled to myself. "I just wish she and Drew would think about getting married or having a baby" and I could feel my smile fading.

There's no way Drew and I can get married because I was actually born a man, which rules out a baby as well, but we can never tell his parents the truth.

I always knew I was female in a male body, long before I was even old enough to articulate that. I'm tall, slim and blonde and ever since I was very young I could easily pass for female, moreover I feel so much more comfortable as a female – it’s natural for me.

When I reached puberty I grew very little facial hair and had very few physical changes which made me seem even more androgynous.

My dad's a big masculine farmer and my mum's very elegant and feminine, but strangely enough it was my dad who was more understanding when I blurted out my feelings to them when I was 16.

I have an older sister and younger brother who are totally normal, if there is such a thing, but I knew I was in the wrong body. I went to our doctor who surprised me by knowing a lot about gender identity disorder and he referred me for a psychological evaluation.

That was nerve wracking because I couldn't help but feel my future was in her hands and I was very worried about answering questions wrongly and being turned down for a sex change.

Decisions over something this major don't happen overnight and I found my psychologist very approachable.

I was given hormone replacement therapy which made my skin much softer and stopped all my facial hair. I also grew a tiny chest which I was very pleased about as I didn't fancy surgery but I knew that to be a proper woman I would have to face sex reassignment surgery at some point.

When I left home and went to university over 300 kilometres away for the first time in my life I lived as a woman, although I hadn't yet had the operation. I filled in all my forms as female - my name’s Jamie so I didn’t need to worry about changing that part of my identity.

After I finished my second year I went for the operation at a hospital near my parents, planning to recuperate with them. When I woke up I knew something was wrong as all my family were by my bed, clearly exhausted and distraught.

I found out later that during the operation my lungs had collapsed and then my heart stopped so the surgery hadn't continued as all efforts were concentrated on saving my life.

I had to take a year out of university to recover and was absolutely shattered to realise that my dream of being a complete woman looked unlikely ever to happen.

After a lot of support and counselling I completed my degree and shortly afterwards I met Drew. He's not gay and he fell in love with me as a woman but admitting the truth to him was horrendous and at first he really struggled to come to terms with it.

We've been together for over six years and where we live no-one knows the truth, we just look like any other happy, loving, mixed-sex couple.

I work in fashion and have even worked as a model. I do feel that I betray my closest friends by not being totally honest, but for the sake of my relationship with Drew I can't risk even a whisper of this getting out.

I'm still very close to my family and Drew comes with me to see them. But I felt I had to drop all my friends back home. My parents don't understand why we cannot be open with our closest friends, but Drew's parents live near us and he says they would never, ever understand and it would ruin his relationship with them.

When we see Drew's family his mother drops a lot of hints about being a grandmother, which makes us both very uncomfortable.

I get very paranoid about hiding my body and going swimming or wearing very fitting clothes makes me sick with nerves but although I'm very slim and wear special tight underwear I can't relax.

Sometimes I would give anything just to be myself and I have moments when I wonder if I should risk the operation again but I'm scared I might die this time. All I want is to live with the man I love and be the woman he loves, but it's never going to be straightforward.

Your say: Have you had a similar experience? Share your stories and thoughts below.

Earn $200 — submit your own true confession via the feedback form at the top of this confession. Those confessions featured on the website will receive $200.
User comments
Yesterday, for the first time in my 57 years, I admitted that I am one of those unfortunate souls who is a woman living inside a man's body. I admitted it to my wife of 37 years. After a day of reflection, we are both adjusting to this new era in our lives. I don't want to go through the sex change surgery. I am now comfortable with who I am and my partner, who was my wife, and I are going to work toward accepting this new phase in our relationship. Thank you for this posting it has given me a chance to admit who I am first to my partner and next to myself. I love my newly released feminine identity I will let you know how it all turns out!
Actually..her boyfriend is NOT gay...he met a woman, he fell in love with a woman...just sucks that she was born with the wrong body parts & hormones..and has had to deal with that confusion. And his parents don't need to know..it really isn't anyone elses business unless she wants it to be...her body is HER body. And no reason why they can't adopt in the future if they want to...just so long as they dont do it JUST because the mother-in-law wants grandkids!!!
Firstly, this man's partner needs to come to terms with the fact that he is now, at least a technical sense, gay. Yes, he fell in love with a woman but upon discovering that this woman is a man, he has chosen to stay. The fact is he was able to look past this 'technicality'. Most men wouldn't.From these comments it's clear to see that bigotry and homophobia are still alive and thriving.For these two to work it out, the partner need to comes to come to terms with who HE is. This article talks about the struggle of a woman trapped in a mans body, but the partner's struggle is the one that will see the success or failure of their relationship. For him to be able to 'explain' himself to his parents, he needs to be able to explain himself to himself. Even if 'typically' he doesn't consider himself gay...this is his exception. All up I think the partner has to understand who HE is. He needs to be comfortable and confident and then present that person to those closest to him.
I'm not gay and have never had any kind of surgery here or anywhere else. In fact married 36 years tohe same man. I'm just saying Jamie is kidding herself if she thinks the in laws are clueless and don't know. Somehow I don't think so!!!!
To Jamie, As far as your partner goes, if your partner loves you heaps then he will stay with you no matter what. But there are more people in the world nowadays that are accepting of us than those that are not. I have told every single person who is important in my life and not a single one has rejected me or my partner. If you do however get someone who is not accepting of it, I believe they were never a friend to begin with.
To Hilda, your views are completely wrong, it's not selfish that we want to do this, it's because we love other people so much that we don't do anything earlier. Along with the fact that it takes a long time to come to grips with yourself about what is going on. To Antiputz, There are no defining marks that can point out a transperson at all. Those who want to blend in learn to do it with such perfection that you will never know the difference without getting them naked. I myself have a lovely partner and no visible adams apple. I also go swimming and sun baking regularly, but you would never know then either. Even people who knew me before hand have a hard time realising it's the same person, and they have known me for years. I quite often tell people about me and they don't believe me.
Some of these comments truly sicken and sadden me. How dare you, Hilda, say such things as you did. Granted, everyone is entitled to their own opinion but to say that she was born male and so should be and act a male is completely out of line. Do you have any idea what it is like to live in a body that does not do what your mind tells you it should do? To not look and feel like how it should? I am heterosexual, however my best friend is trans and with gender identity disorder. He was born female but is a man trapped in a woman's body. Also Hilda, why do you tell this couple not to adopt? Why do you inherently think that they will make the children "suffer"? Walk a mile in Jamie's shoes or any trans person's and then try and voice your biased and hurtful opinions. No one likes to be judged for something they cannot help. Do you have any idea what it does to a person's psyche? No of course not 'cos judging by your comments you clearly are not able to empathize with humans or any being.
Wow.. What a waste of reading time I won't get back. I feel for you on the level that you are living life to someone elses desires.. not your own. At the same time I have to think "Are you Serious?" No One cares, except him.. You have a penis... 6 years? He's gay. He's gay and doesn't want to come-out hence being with you. He gets a secret gay lover in the form fitting for his parents. You really need to re-evaluate this. Once you no longer have male goodies, He probably wouldn't even want you. Harsh.. but logically true
I am questioning the validity of this confession.I think Jamie is making this confession up to get the story in print. I have been through the gender reassignment journey and for starters if you start female hormones after puberty it does not eliminate facial hair.Only electrolysis does it permanently.hormones reduce most body hair only.Secondly to say you had the surgery near your house is unlikely as the only surgeon performing the procedure in Australia at the moment is Dr Ciber in melborne and you must go through 2years minimum of assessments by the Monash University gender reassignment team before he will operate.
With all due respect, the notion of "a woman in a man's body" or 'a man in a woman's body' sounds like sexism in light of comments like "I'm tall, slim and blonde and ever since I was very young I could easily pass for female...". Such a mode of thinking inadvertently imposes specific social and physical, although non-genital, criteria to masculinity and femininity and therefore implicitly promotes 'traditional western' gender roles which were the subject of rejection by early feminists and like-minded individuals. Thus, any failure to find acceptance stems initially not from 'traditionally' minded people but from the failure of such gender challenged individuals to accept and respect the body they were born with, provided it is healthy in its own right. Finally, every individual would undoubtedly benefit by realising that masculinity and femininity are in the eye of the beholder and nobody, therefore, should ever feel less a man or woman because of contemporary stereotypes.

Write a comment
Email: *
Your email will not be shared with any third parties or published with your comment.
Nickname: *
Location: *

Subject:
*
Comment:
*
Maximum characters 1000

Comment guidelines
Avoid using:
  • Personal attacks
  • Irrelevant comments
  • HTML tags
  • Personal information
  • Offensive language
  • Text in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
See full comment guidelines
Comment guidelines X
Thank you for sharing your opinions with other users of NineMSN. People will find your comments more helpful if you include relevant information and avoid some common pitfalls.
Please note: All reviews and comments submitted are subject to moderation, NineMSN reserves the right to alter and / or remove any content that does not comply with usage guidelines.
What to include in your comment:
  • A title that briefly summarizes the opinion expressed in the comment.
  • Additional comments adding more detail.
  • Comparisons to other similar products, if this is relevant.
  • To create a new paragraph, press the Enter key twice.
What not to include:
  • Information that will quickly go out of date.
  • Comments on other comments or commenters.
  • Language that other users may find offensive.
  • comments of one sentence or less. Provide information to support your opinion.
  • Personal information like your email address or telephone number.
  • HTML coding. Tags like <b> or <i> will not be recognized.
advertisement
advertisement

VIDEOS

PHOTOS

ARTICLES

Kim Kardashian is a Bikini Babe in MexicoKim Kardashian is a Bikini Babe in Mexico Weird Anna Nicole Smith nude photos released (video NSFW!)Weird Anna Nicole Smith nude photos released (video NSFW!) Valentine's Day - Hollywood's Happiest CouplesValentine's Day - Hollywood's Happiest Couples

Today's top 5

Sandra Bullock jokes about Jesse James' infidelitySandra Bullock jokes about Jesse James' infidelitySandra Bullock has joked about her marriage breakdown, during her first public appearance since she split from husband Jesse James. Ernie Dingo's wife: We have Ernie Dingo's wife: We have "an understanding" about our marriageTV star Ernie Dingo has been accused of cheating on his wife in a series of damning reports. Now Sally Dingo, his wife of 21 years, writes exclusively for Woman’s Day about their unique marriage deal. Angelina Jolie's new cheating claimsAngelina Jolie's new cheating claimsCelebrity biographer Andrew Morton’s claims that Angelina Jolie had secret affairs with six Hollywood stars – including another married man – were revealed for the first time last week. 90210 star Ian Ziering's wedding90210 star Ian Ziering's weddingIt was a Beverly Hills, 90210 reunion when original cast member Ian Ziering - ho played rich kid Steve Sanders on the hit ’90s teen drama - married nurse Erin Ludwig at Newport Beach, California, recently. Weather man Steve Jacobs ties the knot!Weather man Steve Jacobs ties the knot!Their love story had a stormy start, but it was nothing but clear skies when the popular weather presenters said ‘I do’ in Bali. Clare Rigden writes.

Your say

Most commented

True Confessions Agony Aunt: I hate my StepsonTrue Confessions Agony Aunt: I hate my StepsonAre you kidding me?? For all these people who have commented " you don't know what it's like to be a step parent" blah blah blah.... who are you trying to kid?? And for those saying that you have your own kids and step kids and the step kids are manipulative etc etc, are you blind and dumb? Your kids are not perfect either i bet! I bet your kids are just as rude when you are not around! I have a 12 year old daughter and i have been with my partner for 5 years. He struggles alot with my daughter because she gives him hell. She has said several times she wishes it was just me and her again, but because my partner loves me he sticks it out and knows that it's just her trying to get her own way. He loves her and would do anything for her no matter what she does, that's what's good parents do. If you can't warm to a child or don't like your soon to be step child then dont marry the parent. You are just being selfish otherwise. Just imagine if the shoe was on the other foot...b81die, Brisbane29 CommentsPost commentView comments
True Confessions Agony Aunt: I hate my StepsonTrue Confessions Agony Aunt: I hate my StepsonAre you kidding me?? For all these people who have commented " you don't know what it's like to be a step parent" blah blah blah.... who are you trying to kid?? And for those saying that you have your own kids and step kids and the step kids are manipulative etc etc, are you blind and dumb? Your kids are not perfect either i bet! I bet your kids are just as rude when you are not around! I have a 12 year old daughter and i have been with my partner for 5 years. He struggles alot with my daughter because she gives him hell. She has said several times she wishes it was just me and her again, but because my partner loves me he sticks it out and knows that it's just her trying to get her own way. He loves her and would do anything for her no matter what she does, that's what's good parents do. If you can't warm to a child or don't like your soon to be step child then dont marry the parent. You are just being selfish otherwise. Just imagine if the shoe was on the other foot...b81die, Brisbane29 CommentsPost commentView comments Delta exclusive: 'I never said I was perfect!'Delta exclusive: 'I never said I was perfect!'Delta had cancer at a very young age, she fought for her life. Yes the type of cancer was one of the least lethal but none the less she had cancer attacking her body. she had chemo, i've watched some of my closest friends on chemo and it is always so horrific. She has pushed past that and made brilliant songs. Her music is heartfelt. She sis so beautiful and in her flim clips she dresses with dignity and respect unlike other artist who just let everything hang out and sing about sex, drugs and alcohol. She was put on the voice because she is ment to be there the people who run the show chose her. don't like it ? simple don't watch it. If you don't like her as an artist fine, don't buy her albums. She is human and she has feelings, give the woman a break.Cathh.Ann, QLD, Gold Coast27 CommentsPost commentView comments Darren Hayes dishes: I know the real DeltaDarren Hayes dishes: I know the real DeltaI love her !!wiz, melbourne16 CommentsPost commentView comments Grant and Candice: Why they splitGrant and Candice: Why they splitGive the guy a break! He went to functions, where there was probably free booze, and got drunk on 2 separate occasions. It does sound like maybe he drinks a little too much, but hey free booze who doesn't........., ..........12 CommentsPost commentView comments Keith Urban tells: My second chanceKeith Urban tells: My second chancethey are a fabulous couple! he is very attractive and he has a beautiful voice! i would have been so upset if anything had happened to it! Go keith and nic! wooash, wollongong7 CommentsPost commentView comments